Minority stakes and discounts
Why a minority shareholding in a Belgian company is often valued differently from a proportional share of the whole, and how discounts are reasoned in a report.
A minority stake does not carry the same rights as a controlling interest, since a minority shareholder cannot unilaterally decide on dividends, strategy, or a sale of the company. Independent valuation reports often reflect this by applying a discount to a proportional share of the company's overall value, reasoned from the specific rights attached to that stake.
- A minority stake lacks control rights over dividends, strategy and sale decisions.
- Discounts for lack of control and lack of marketability are assessed separately.
- The statutory formula applies uniformly, regardless of the size of the stake held.
Ownership percentage is not the same as proportional value
If a company as a whole is valued at a given figure, it does not automatically follow that a shareholder owning a given percentage holds shares worth exactly that percentage of the total. Control over a company carries value in itself, since a controlling shareholder can decide on dividend policy, strategic direction, management appointments and an eventual sale.
A minority shareholder holds none of these levers individually. Their position depends on how the majority chooses to run the company, which introduces a difference between a strict proportional calculation and what the stake is reasonably worth on its own terms.
Two distinct discounts are commonly discussed
A discount for lack of control reflects the absence of decision-making power over the company's affairs. A separate discount for lack of marketability reflects the fact that shares in a private company, particularly a minority position, cannot readily be sold on an open market the way listed shares can, and finding a buyer may take time and effort.
These two discounts address different aspects of the same underlying issue and are considered separately in a well-reasoned valuation report, rather than combined into a single unexplained adjustment.
The size of a discount depends on the specific circumstances
Whether and how much a discount applies depends on factors such as the existence of shareholder agreements granting minority protections, the company's dividend history, and any provisions governing an eventual exit for minority holders. A minority position protected by strong contractual rights may warrant a smaller discount than one with no such protections.
Ter illustratie, a minority shareholder entitled to a guaranteed dividend under a shareholders agreement is in a materially different position from one with no such entitlement, even if both hold an identical percentage of the same company.
The statutory formula does not distinguish stake size
The statutory formula calculates a value for the company as a whole, based on equity and EBITDA, and applies the resulting per-share figure uniformly regardless of whether the shareholder in question holds a controlling stake or a small minority. It does not incorporate any adjustment for control or marketability.
Why this matters for shareholders reviewing their position
A shareholder holding a minority stake in a company with no formal protections may find that a reasoned valuation, accounting for the realities of that position, produces a materially different figure from a straightforward proportional calculation. Reviewing the relevant shareholder agreement alongside the company's accounts is a useful starting point.
Questions on this
Do all minority stakes receive the same discount
No. The size of a discount, if any, depends on the specific rights and protections attached to the stake, such as shareholder agreement provisions, rather than a fixed percentage applied uniformly.
What is the difference between the two types of discount discussed
A discount for lack of control reflects the absence of decision-making power, while a discount for lack of marketability reflects the difficulty of selling a private minority stake. They are assessed on separate grounds.
Does the statutory formula apply discounts for minority stakes
No. The formula produces a single per-share figure for the company as a whole and applies it uniformly, without adjustment for whether the shareholder holds a controlling or minority position.
Open a file
Enter your details and we will get in touch shortly.
Read next
This information is general. It does not take your specific situation into account and is not tax advice.